Positive Life NSW Blog

HIV law: It’s time for change

Posted by on in Advocacy and Policy

IMAGE: A man writes on glass - Know Your Rights

We call for a sensible and mature approach to HIV to reflect the modern realities of HIV treatments and prevention strategies for both HIV- and HIV+ people.

Criminal charges against a Sydney man relating to his alleged infection of a former partner with HIV hit the headlines in early January. Disturbingly, one major newspaper published the man’s name and a photo lifted from his social media page.

Criminalising HIV discourages testing, encourages anonymous sex, and leads to increased HIV-related discrimination and stigma. None support public health efforts to end HIV infection.

As it currently stands, NSW public health law says you must tell your partner if you have HIV, before you have sex, or that you must take ‘reasonable precautions’ such as using condoms and water based lube. In terms of transmitting the virus and maintaining good health, the modern reality of HIV as a manageable chronic condition stands in direct contrast to the current legislation.

Positive Life believes HIV transmission and acquisition should be addressed and dealt with solely as a health issue under public health law in NSW, and not as a criminal issue. We advocate for and support changes to the Public Health Act to reflect the modern reality.

Today, treatments for HIV can successfully suppress the virus. If a person with HIV has an undetectable viral load and no sexually transmitted infections, then the chances of condomless sex resulting in HIV infection are low. This is known as ‘treatment as prevention’, or TasP. However, without changes to the law or a court deciding that an undetectable viral load is a ‘reasonable precaution’, a person with HIV can still be in breach of the Public Health Act for not disclosing their HIV status before sex.

Now there’s PrEP, or ‘pre-exposure prophylaxis’. One of the great benefits of PrEP is it means HIV-negative people can take control of their own health and reduce their own risk of acquiring HIV. So where does this new prevention strategy fit with the current NSW legal approach to HIV?

Disclosure of our status as a person with HIV can, in rare circumstances, lead to violence. More often it leads to rejection, loss of control of the disclosure of our status to others, discrimination and the premature ending of relationships.

As a person with HIV, the suggestion that I could be charged with a criminal offence in relation to infecting another person with HIV is horrifying. The possibility that my name and my photo could be plastered on the webpage of a major newspaper before I’ve had any chance to defend the charge is even more horrifying.

So what do I do? Do I disclose my status and face possible rejection and discrimination? Do I reject potential fucks who are HIV-negative, sero-sort and choose only to have sex with others who are HIV-positive? Or do I engage solely in anonymous sex, which entails risks for both me and my partner?

It is clear that in NSW we need a sensible and mature approach to HIV which reflects the modern realities of treatments and prevention strategies and which balances the individual rights and responsibilities of both HIV-positive and negative people.

Also at: SX/GNN

Last modified on


  • Guest
    Rob Tuesday, 19 January 2016

    As I understand it, it was the Magistrate, Greg Grogin, that refused a suppression order on the identity of the alleged offender, even though he had approved a suppression order on the identity of the alleged victim.

    Seems, given how out-of-touch our esteemed Magistrates appear to be, that suppression orders for both offender and victim should be mandatory.

Leave your comment

Guest Saturday, 28 March 2020

Givenow - make a secure online donation to Positive Life NSWLocation: Suite 5.2, Level 5, 414 Elizabeth Street, Surry Hills NSW 2010
Postal: PO Box 831, Darlinghurst NSW 1300

Telephone: 02 9206 2177 or 1800 245 677 (freecall)
TTY: 131 450    Fax: 02 9211 5672

proudly sponsored by    website design and build by

digialpac                            avernis

Images used are stock photos and do not imply any HIV status, sexuality or behaviours.